Picking a residential proxy provider looks easy until you start reading. Every site claims the biggest pool, the best success rate and the lowest price, and the numbers rarely line up. One provider’s pricing page even lists two different pay-as-you-go rates for the same product, according to one review that caught it. Meanwhile your budget, your targets and your risk tolerance are specific to you.
This guide cuts through that. It compares the four residential proxy providers that come up most often for serious work (Bright Data, Oxylabs, Decodo and IPRoyal), flags a few alternatives, and shows you how to decide, and then verify, which one fits your project. If you are brand new to the topic, start with our explainer on what residential proxies are and the full residential proxies hub, then come back.
How this ranking was made: We did not run our own benchmark for this edition. The comparison rests on providers’ published pages, independent review sites and benchmark reports (several dated 2026), and cross-checks between sources. Where numbers conflict, we say so. Pool sizes are advertised figures, not verified counts, and prices change often, so confirm everything on the provider’s site before you pay.
The quick answer
| Your situation | Shortlist | Why |
| Enterprise, compliance reviews, huge scale | Bright Data or Oxylabs | Largest advertised pools, formal compliance processes, wide product range |
| Mid-size team that wants a dependable all-rounder | Decodo | Large pool, self-serve, strong results in independent testing |
| Small budget or uneven usage | IPRoyal | Pay-as-you-go with traffic that does not expire |
| Rock-bottom per-GB price | Newer budget networks (see the alternatives section) | Cheaper, but check sourcing and quality carefully |
How we compared providers
A price per gigabyte tells you very little by itself. These are the factors that actually decide whether a provider works for you:
- Sourcing and compliance. How are IPs obtained, and is there documentation you can show a lawyer or a client?
- Real pool size and spread. Advertised numbers are marketing. What matters is how many distinct, live IPs you get in your target cities.
- Success rate and speed on your targets. A provider that shines on one site may struggle on another.
- Pricing structure. Pay-as-you-go versus monthly commitments, minimum spend, and whether unused traffic expires.
- Targeting and session control. Country, state, city, rotation, and sticky sessions.
- Support and onboarding. Including know-your-customer (KYC) checks, which slow some providers down.
The big comparison table
| Provider | Advertised residential pool | Reported pricing (verify before buying) | Best for |
| Bright Data | 400M+ IPs, 195 countries | Pay-as-you-go listed at $8/GB with promos as low as $4/GB; monthly plans from $499 (141 GB) down to about $2.50/GB at 798 GB | Enterprise scale, fine-grained targeting, compliance-heavy buyers |
| Oxylabs | 175M+ IPs, 195 locations | Published tiers from about $6/GB at the small starter plan to about $2.50/GB at 1 TB | Large, performance-critical, business buyers |
| Decodo (formerly Smartproxy) | 115M+ IPs | Reviews cite roughly $3.50 to $3.75/GB entry, falling with volume; site shows inconsistent pay-as-you-go figures | Mid-market teams wanting a dependable self-serve option |
| IPRoyal | 32M+ IPs, 195 countries | Pay-as-you-go around $7/GB at 1 GB, falling to about $1.75/GB at bulk; traffic never expires | Small budgets, irregular usage |
A note on those prices. The sources we read disagree with each other, partly because of promotions and partly because providers change their grids. Treat this table as a guide to relative positioning (Bright Data and Oxylabs at the premium end, IPRoyal and Decodo friendlier to smaller buyers) rather than a quote.
1. Bright Data: best for enterprise scale and control
Bright Data advertises the biggest residential network in the market, at 400 million or more IPs across 195 countries. Its own pricing page offers both pay-as-you-go and committed monthly plans, and independent reviewers describe it as the most complete provider on coverage, products and targeting, with targeting that goes down to city, ZIP code and network (ASN) level.
What it does well
- Scale and coverage. The pool size gives you more room before IPs repeat and more depth in smaller markets.
- Granular targeting. One comparison describes it as offering the most detailed geo-targeting of any residential provider.
- Documented compliance. Residential accounts go through a KYC process, and the company publishes consent documentation, which matters if a client or lawyer asks where your IPs come from.
- Beyond proxies. Unblocking APIs, scraping tools and datasets sit alongside the proxy network.
Where it falls short
- Price. Even with promos, it is among the costliest per GB, according to several reviewers.
- Commitments. The cheapest per-GB rates require a monthly plan. The entry plan costs $499 a month and includes 141 GB, so if you only use 100 GB, you are effectively paying close to $5 per GB.
- Complexity. The dashboard is feature-rich and not the easiest for beginners.
Choose it if you have a serious budget, need city-level precision, or must show a clean compliance trail. Skip it if you are experimenting or your usage is small and uneven. Our full Bright Data review goes deeper.
2. Oxylabs: best for large, performance-focused business use
Oxylabs advertises 175 million or more residential IPs in 195 locations. In Proxyway’s April 2026 benchmark, it had the largest pool of the providers tested, with small-page response times around 0.6 seconds, which is quick for residential traffic. Another vendor’s live-pool test found its US coverage narrowly the deepest it had measured, although the lead was uneven across countries.
What it does well
- Pool depth and reliability in independent testing.
- Formal ethical-sourcing position and documentation suited to institutional due diligence.
- Enterprise ecosystem. Scraper APIs, unblocking tools and managed data services.
Where it falls short
- Premium pricing. Published tiers start around $6 per GB for the small starter plan and only reach $2.50 per GB at 1 TB. At about 100 GB a month, one analysis puts you near $4 per GB.
- Sales-led onboarding. Free trials are arranged through sales, and KYC applies.
- Not built for tinkerers. Small projects get better value elsewhere.
Choose it if reliability and depth matter more than price. Skip it if you spend less than a few hundred dollars a month. See our Oxylabs review for details, and our Bright Data vs. Oxylabs comparison if you are torn between the two.
3. Decodo (formerly Smartproxy): best mid-market all-rounder
Smartproxy rebranded as Decodo; reviewers confirm the network, dashboard and pricing structure carried over, so older Smartproxy reviews still describe this service. Decodo advertises 115 million or more residential IPs. Proxyway’s April 2026 testing found its pool second only to Oxylabs in size, with a success rate of 99.95% in its test, and a separate vendor study measured it within about 1% of the largest live pool across five countries.
What it does well
- Strong results for the price. Independent testers describe performance close to the premium providers at lower cost.
- Self-serve and flexible. Pay-as-you-go is available, and you can top up plans at the same per-GB rate.
- Good targeting and protocol support. HTTP(S) and SOCKS5, with targeting down to city level and ZIP code for US traffic.
- Support. Reviewers consistently mention 24/7 customer support.
Where it falls short
- Confusing pricing. One reviewer found the company’s own page showing $4 per GB on the pricing grid and $8.50 for 1 GB in the wallet FAQ. Check the checkout total before committing.
- Entry price is not the lowest. Cheaper options exist for tiny budgets.
Choose it if you want a dependable provider without enterprise contracts. Read our Decodo review for pricing specifics.
4. IPRoyal: best for small budgets and irregular usage
IPRoyal offers 32 million or more residential IPs in 195 countries, with country, state and city targeting at no extra cost, rotating or sticky sessions (up to 7 days) and HTTP(S) and SOCKS5 support, according to its documentation. Its standout feature is that purchased residential traffic does not expire, which is unusual in this market.
What it does well
- Non-expiring traffic. If your usage comes in bursts, you do not lose unused gigabytes at the end of a billing cycle.
- Low entry barrier. No contract, with bulk pricing falling to about $1.75 per GB according to a 2026 review.
- Consent-based sourcing claims. IPRoyal says its residential IPs are ethically sourced through an opt-in app. One competitor’s comparison notes it emphasizes GDPR and CCPA compliance but lacks a third-party certification, so ask for specifics.
Where it falls short
- Smaller pool. 32 million is a fraction of the leaders’ advertised sizes, which can matter in niche locations or at very high volume.
- Small-purchase price. Pay-as-you-go at 1 GB is far above the bulk rate.
- Performance varies by target. One comparison reported strong results on Amazon but weaker datacenter figures, so test your own targets.
Choose it if your budget is tight or your workload is uneven. Our IPRoyal review has the details.
Other providers worth knowing
The market is bigger than four names. A few others appear frequently in independent roundups:
- SOAX: advertises about 155 million residential IPs and is known for flexible filtering options. One review listed an entry plan around $99 a month.
- DataImpulse: advertises a consent-based pool of about 90 million IPs at roughly $1 per GB pay-as-you-go on its own site. Independent reviewers call it cheap with some trade-offs, so test before scaling.
- NetNut and Webshare: both turn up in 2026 comparisons. Webshare is cheap; one review notes it is owned by Oxylabs. Verify current terms and sourcing for either.
We have not evaluated these in the same depth, so use the checklist below before buying any of them.
Which provider for which job?
| Use case | What to prioritize |
| Large-scale web scraping | Pool depth and success rate: Oxylabs, Bright Data, or Decodo. Read our web scraping guide first. |
| Ad verification | City-level targeting and clean sourcing: Bright Data, Decodo |
| SEO and SERP tracking | Accurate local IPs in many cities; moderate volume: Decodo or IPRoyal |
| Price monitoring on a budget | Flexible billing: IPRoyal or Decodo |
| Enterprise or regulated work | Documentation and KYC: Bright Data or Oxylabs |
| Short, bursty projects | Traffic that does not expire: IPRoyal |
How much will it really cost? A worked example
Per-GB headlines mislead because of minimum commitments. Take a team that scrapes about 100 GB per month.
- On a plan that costs $499 and includes 141 GB, you pay $499 whether you use 100 GB or 141 GB. Effective rate: about $4.99 per GB at 100 GB.
- On pay-as-you-go at a list rate of $8 per GB, 100 GB would run about $800 before any promotion.
- On a provider with non-expiring pay-as-you-go traffic, a lean month can leave a balance for the next one.
Your own bill also depends on page weight and retries. Blocking images and unnecessary scripts can cut bandwidth substantially, and a provider with a higher success rate often costs less overall than a cheaper one that forces repeated requests. Our residential proxy pricing guide walks through this in detail.
How to test providers yourself in one afternoon
Reviews, including this one, are a starting point. The only result that counts is how a provider performs on your targets. Most offer a trial or small starter plan. Run the same test on each:
- Pick 50 to 100 representative URLs from your real targets.
- Request them through each provider using the same settings and the same location.
- Record the success rate, average response time and gigabytes used.
- Compare cost per successful page, not cost per GB.
Here is a small Python starting point:
import requests, time
PROXY = “http://USER:PASS@gateway.provider.com:PORT”
urls = [line.strip() for line in open(‘urls.txt’)]
ok, total_time = 0, 0
for u in urls:
start = time.time()
try:
r = requests.get(u, proxies={‘http’: PROXY, ‘https’: PROXY}, timeout=30)
if r.status_code == 200:
ok += 1
except Exception:
pass
total_time += time.time() – start
print(f’Success: {ok}/{len(urls)} Avg time: {total_time/len(urls):.2f}s’)
Only run this against sites and at request rates you are permitted to use, and respect each target’s terms.
Red flags when choosing a provider
- Vague sourcing. If a company cannot explain how it gets its IPs, walk away.
- Prices far below the market for a supposedly premium pool.
- No KYC or acceptable-use policy at all. It sounds convenient, but it often signals weak controls.
- Hidden minimums and expiring traffic buried in the checkout.
- Free proxy lists. These are slow, unreliable and sometimes malicious.
- Results quoted without methodology. Be wary of any “success rate” with no test details.
The legal and ethical side, briefly
Using a residential proxy is legal in most places, including the United States, but your choices still matter. Prefer providers with consent-based sourcing, keep records of why you picked them, and make sure what you do with the proxy is lawful and consistent with the target’s terms. Collecting personal data brings privacy rules such as California’s CCPA into play. This is general information, not legal advice, so talk to an attorney if your project is large or sensitive. Our guide to proxy legal considerations covers the topic.
Final verdict
There is no single best residential proxy provider, only the best one for your situation. If money is no object and compliance matters, start with Bright Data or Oxylabs. If you want strong performance without enterprise overhead, Decodo is the sensible middle. If your budget is small or your usage comes in waves, IPRoyal’s non-expiring traffic is hard to beat. Whichever you pick, run the afternoon test above before committing real money.
Frequently asked questions
Which is the best residential proxy provider in 2026?
It depends on your needs. Bright Data and Oxylabs lead on scale and enterprise features, Decodo is a strong mid-market all-rounder, and IPRoyal suits small budgets and irregular usage.
What is the cheapest residential proxy provider?
Newer budget networks and IPRoyal’s bulk tiers advertise some of the lowest per-GB rates, but the cheapest option is not always the cheapest in practice. Poor success rates mean more retries and a bigger bill.
Is Decodo the same as Smartproxy?
Yes. Smartproxy rebranded as Decodo, and reviewers report the network, dashboard and pricing structure carried over.
Do residential proxy providers require ID verification?
Some do. Bright Data and Oxylabs run KYC checks on residential accounts. Self-serve providers are usually quicker to start.
How big should a residential proxy pool be?
Bigger is not always better. A small project at modest request rates will never exhaust a mid-sized pool. What matters more is quality and coverage in your target locations.
Are free residential proxies safe?
Generally no. Free lists are often slow, unreliable and sometimes malicious, logging traffic or stealing credentials.
How do I choose between per-GB and per-IP pricing?
Per-GB suits rotating pools and varied tasks. Per-IP suits static setups where you need a stable address, such as managing accounts.